Waterjet vs Laser Cutting: 7 Key Differences

Choosing between waterjet and laser cutting? Here's what you need to know:

1. Cutting Method: Waterjet uses high-pressure water, laser uses focused light beam
2. Materials: Waterjet cuts almost anything, laser best for thin metals and non-metals
3. Precision: Laser more precise (±0.002") than waterjet (±0.005")
4. Thickness: Waterjet handles up to 4", laser typically under 0.5"
5. Speed: Laser faster (20-70 in/min) than waterjet (1-20 in/min)
6. Heat Effects: Waterjet has none, laser can alter material properties
7. Costs: Waterjet pricier to run ($15-$30/hr vs $13-$20/hr for laser)

Quick Comparison:

Bottom line: Pick waterjet for thick or heat-sensitive stuff, laser for thin materials and speed.

Related video from YouTube

1. How They Cut

Waterjet and laser cutting are two different ways to shape materials. Let's look at how each works.

Waterjet Cutting Basics

Waterjet cutting uses a high-pressure water stream, often mixed with abrasive particles, to erode materials. Think of it as a super-powered version of how water carved the Grand Canyon.

Here's the process:

• Water is pressurized to about 60,000 PSI
• It's forced through a tiny hole (0.010" to 0.015" wide)
• This creates a powerful jet that cuts through almost anything

Waterjet machines typically output 4 to 7 kilowatts of power. They can cut materials 0.4" to 2.0" thick at speeds up to 20 inches per minute.

Laser Cutting Basics

Laser cutting uses a focused light beam to melt, burn, or vaporize materials. It's more precise but limited in what it can cut.

The process:

• A laser beam is generated (usually by fiber optic cable)
• The beam is focused through a lens
• It heats the material, causing it to melt or vaporize

Laser cutters can output between 4 and 6000 watts. They work best on materials up to 0.4" thick and can cut at speeds up to 70 inches per minute.

Key Differences

Main differences:

1. Heat: Waterjet is cold, laser is hot. Waterjet is better for heat-sensitive materials.
2. Speed: Laser is faster for thin materials, waterjet for thick ones.
3. Precision: Laser is more precise (0.006" vs waterjet's 0.02").
4. Material range: Waterjet cuts almost anything. Laser is more limited but great for metals.
5. Byproducts: Waterjet creates more waste and noise. Laser can produce toxic fumes with some materials.

CAMM Metals says: "Waterjet cutting is a cold process and does not put any heat into the material during the cutting process." This makes it ideal for industries like aerospace, where material integrity is key.

2. Materials They Can Cut

Waterjet and laser cutting excel with different materials. Here's the breakdown:

Waterjet's Sweet Spot

Waterjet cutting is the Swiss Army knife of cutting tools. It handles:

• Metals: From aluminum to hardened steel
• Stone: Marble, granite, even concrete
• Composites: Carbon fiber, fiberglass, Kevlar
• Glass: Thin smartphone screens to thick bulletproof panels
• Plastics and rubber: Without warping

"OMAX systems cut more aluminum than any other metal. It's fast and clean."

Waterjet loves thick materials. It slices through 12 inches of steel as accurately as thinner pieces.

Laser's Forte

Laser cutting shines with:

• Thin metals: Mild steel, stainless steel, aluminum alloys
• Wood: For intricate designs
• Plastics: Acrylic and polycarbonate
• Organic materials: Paper, cardboard, leather

Laser cutting thickness limits:

Each Method's Limits

Waterjet cuts almost anything but isn't always the best choice. Laser cutting is faster for thin materials but has more limitations.

"Waterjet cutting marble countertops is easy. No chipping like with a saw."

Waterjet uses no heat, perfect for heat-sensitive materials. Laser offers high precision for thin materials, despite its limitations.

3. Precision and Accuracy

Precision and accuracy are crucial in cutting methods. Let's compare waterjet and laser cutting:

Waterjet Precision

Waterjet cutting is precise, but not as fine as laser:

• Minimum cutting slit: 0.02" (0.5 mm)
• Typical tolerance: +/- 0.008" (0.2 mm)

It maintains tight accuracies for materials up to 4" thick and can cut up to 15" thick, though precision may drop.

Laser Precision

Laser cutting shines in precision, especially for thin materials:

• Minimum cutting slit: 0.006" (0.15 mm)
• Typical tolerance: +/- 0.002" (0.05 mm)

Perfect for intricate designs and tight tolerances.

Accuracy Factors

Both methods can be highly accurate with proper setup. For extreme precision (< 0.001" tolerances), consider EDM cutting.

"In aerospace, we use laser cutting for thin sheet metal parts due to high precision. For thicker components, we go with waterjet", says Tom Chen, a Boeing manufacturing engineer.

4. Cutting Speed

Laser and waterjet cutting speeds differ significantly:

Waterjet Speed

Waterjet cutting is slower:

• 1-20 inches per minute (ipm)
• Better for thick materials (>1 inch)

Laser Speed

Laser cutting is faster:

• 20-1000 ipm
• Great for thin materials (<0.5 inches)

For thin sheet metal, high-power fiber lasers (>4kW) can cut up to 80-100 times faster than waterjet.

Speed Factors

"We use laser cutting for thin sheet metal parts in aerospace due to speed and precision. For thicker parts, we use waterjet", - Tom Chen, Boeing manufacturing engineer.

Choosing between waterjet and laser depends on the job's specific needs, balancing speed with material type, thickness, and heat sensitivity.

5. Material Thickness

Waterjet and laser cutting handle thickness differently. Here's how:

Waterjet: The Thick Material Champion

Waterjet cutting crushes it with thick materials:

• Abrasive waterjet: Cuts up to 12 inches of most materials
• Pure waterjet: Slices through soft materials several feet thick

Flow International Corporation's systems? They can cut 9 inches of stainless steel. Some even reach 18 inches!

Laser: Thin Material Specialist

Laser cutting has limits:

• Typical range: 0.12 to 0.4 inches
• Non-reflective metals max: About 1 inch

But high-power fiber lasers push boundaries:

Picking the Right Tool

Thickness often decides the method:

• Thin (< 0.5 inches): Laser wins for speed and precision
• Thick (> 1 inch): Waterjet takes the crown

"We use laser cutting for thin sheet metal parts in aerospace due to speed and precision. For thicker parts, we use waterjet", - Tom Chen, Boeing manufacturing engineer.

For the 0.5 to 1 inch range? Consider material type, precision needs, and production volume.

sbb-itb-b5aecec

6. Heat Effects

Waterjet and laser cutting handle heat differently. Let's compare:

Waterjet: The Cool Customer

Waterjet cutting is cold. No heat means:

• No heat-affected zone (HAZ)
• No warping or melting
• Material properties stay intact

Boeing loves this for thick, sensitive aerospace parts.

Laser: Bringing the Heat

Laser cutting melts or vaporizes material. This can cause:

• A heat-affected zone (HAZ)
• Warping or melting of sensitive materials
• Changes in material properties

Laser temperatures can exceed 1000°C. That's hot enough to cause problems for some materials.

Tom Chen, a Boeing manufacturing engineer, says:

"For parts that can't handle heat stress, we always go with waterjet. It's slower, but it keeps the material properties intact."

But laser cutting isn't all bad. It's often faster and more precise for heat-tolerant materials.

The bottom line? Choose waterjet for heat-sensitive materials. Go laser when speed matters and the material can take the heat.

7. Running Costs

Waterjet vs laser cutting: let's talk money.

Waterjet Costs

Waterjet cutting isn't cheap. Here's the deal:

• Machine cost: $30,000
• Pricey abrasives needed
• Water treatment required
• Regular maintenance a must

Laser Costs

Laser cutting? Often easier on the wallet:

• Machine cost: $10,000
• Cuts faster: 20-70 inches/min vs waterjet's 1-20
• Lower hourly operation cost

Cost Breakdown

So, which to choose? It depends. Laser's great for thin materials and high volume. Waterjet? It's your go-to for thick or heat-sensitive stuff.

"Heat-sensitive parts? We always pick waterjet. Slower, sure, but it keeps the material intact", says Tom Chen, Boeing manufacturing engineer.

Bottom line: Know your needs, then pick your tech.

Comparison Table

Here's a breakdown of waterjet vs laser cutting:

So, what's the bottom line?

Waterjet shines with material versatility and thickness range. Laser? It's all about precision and speed for thin materials.

Your choice boils down to your specific needs. Thick or heat-sensitive materials? Go waterjet. Thin materials and high-volume production? Laser might be your best bet.

Just keep in mind: These are average figures. Your mileage may vary depending on the specific machines and materials you're using.

Conclusion

Waterjet or laser cutting? It depends on your project. Here's the breakdown:

Material Thickness

• Waterjet: Handles up to 4" thick
• Laser: Best for under ½"

Speed

• Waterjet: 1-20 inches/minute
• Laser: 20-70 inches/minute

Precision

• Waterjet: Good
• Laser: Better (+/-0.002″ tolerance)

Cost

• Waterjet: $50-$75/hour
• Laser: $2-$3/hour

Heat Impact

• Waterjet: None
• Laser: Can affect material properties

Ask yourself:

1. Material thickness?
2. Heat sensitivity?
3. Production volume?
4. Budget?

Many businesses use both methods. It's about having the right tool for each job.

FAQs

What materials can waterjet and laser cutting handle?

Waterjet cutting tackles a bunch of materials:

• Metals (steel, aluminum, copper)
• Stone
• Glass
• Composites
• Plastics

Laser cutting shines with:

• Thin metals (up to 0.5" thick)
• Wood
• Acrylic
• Paper
• Fabric

How do cutting speeds compare?

Laser cutting zips through thin materials faster.

Which method is more precise?

Laser cutting wins the precision game:

• Laser: +/-0.002" tolerance
• Waterjet: +/-0.005" tolerance

What are the cost differences?

Operating costs:

Initial equipment costs:

• Waterjet cutters: $60,000 - $350,000
• Laser cutters: $250,000 - $1,000,000+

How does material thickness affect the choice?

• Waterjet: Rocks for materials 0.5" to 4" thick
• Laser: Nails it for materials under 0.5" thick

Are there heat-related concerns?

• Waterjet: No heat-affected zone (HAZ)
• Laser: Can create HAZ, possibly changing material properties

Which method is more environmentally friendly?

Waterjet cutting creates less waste and no nasty fumes. Laser cutting can spit out fumes, so you'll need good ventilation.

FAQs

Is water jet cutting better than laser?

It depends on what you need. Here's a quick comparison:

• Laser cutting is faster (20-70 inches/minute vs. waterjet's 1-20 inches/minute)
• Laser offers better precision (+/-0.002" vs. waterjet's +/-0.005")
• Waterjet cuts thicker materials (up to 4") and a wider variety
• Waterjet doesn't create heat, making it better for heat-sensitive materials

What are the disadvantages of water jet cutting?

Waterjet cutting has some drawbacks:

1. Slower speed

Especially for thin materials, it's generally slower than laser cutting.

2. Higher costs

It typically costs $15-$30 per hour, compared to $13-$20 for laser cutting.

3. Maintenance issues

Low-quality orifices can break down, causing downtime.

4. Water usage

It requires a lot of water, which can be a problem in some areas.

5. Noise levels

It's often louder than laser cutting, potentially needing extra noise protection.